The ideology of Jeremy Corbyn, the British Labour Party leader, is based on a series of myths - the obverse of the truth. Lyn Julius debunks them in the Jewish Chronicle:
In 2013, Corbyn and a panel of speakers at a Hamas conference were asked by a member of the audience about Jewish refugees from Arab lands. Listen to their response here.
Hardly a day goes by without another shocking revelation of Jeremy
Corbyn's association with antisemites. But while most of us recoil at
Corbyn's documented support for his 'friends' Hamas and Hezbollah, his
appearances on the Iranian-funded Press TV, and his tribute to the
perpetrators of the Munich massacre, little has been said about the
intellectual underpinnings of an ideological worldview that Corbyn has
clung to for 40 years. It is time that they were debunked from a
Sephardi or Mizrahi perspective.
I doubt whether Corbyn has heard
of Mizrahi or Sephardi Jews. Did he know that 850,000 Jewish refugees
fled Arab and Muslim antisemitism in a single generation? Would it appal
him that ancient communities once numbering thousands of Jews - from Morocco in the West to Yemen in the East – were
driven to extinction (barely 4, 500 are left), their property stolen and
their rich heritage erased? Maybe he will blame the Zionists - or say
that the Jews left of their own free will.
The evidence of a
forced Jewish exodus is incontrovertible, however. The Jews
fled in larger numbers than the Palestinians from Israel. The majority
of Jews escaped harassment, intimidation, violence and persecution –
ranging from arrests and imprisonment to execution on trumped-up
charges. Theirs was the largest mass movement of non-Muslims until the
post-2003 flight of Christians from Iraq.
Clearly, Corbyn's
revulsion for the state of Israel lies at the heart of his belief
system. Many believe that he has been reluctant to accept the International Holocaust
Remembrance Alliance definition of antisemitism so that he might
continue to call the Jewish state 'racist' and make offensive
comparisons between Zionists and Nazis. He insists on distinguishing
between ‘good’ anti-Zionist Jews and ‘bad’ Jews - the great majority of whom identify with
Israel.
Yet the bitter experiences of Middle Eastern and North
African Jews teach us that the distinction between Jews and Zionists
cannot be maintained for long. Arab states criminalised Zionism but soon
conflated Zionists with Jews, albeit these were non-combatants. In
Iraq, Jews wearing watches were arrested for 'sending secret signals to
the Zionists'. The Jewish quarters of North African cities became fair
game for attack by vengeful mobs. Anti-Zionist Jews in Egypt were
imprisoned. Sooner or later, Jews are persecuted for being Jews.
Central to Corbyn's worldview is that Israel is a European, white,
settler, colonial, imperialist state. Israel is accused of being built
on the ethnic cleansing of an indigenous population. The injustice to
the Palestinians can only be rectified if they achieve national
liberation through their 'right of return', leading to the destruction
of the Jewish state by demographic means.
This myth turns the
truth on its head. Originating in Judea, Jews had been settled in the
Middle East and North Africa since Biblical times – 1,000 years before
the Islamic conquest. Comprising some three million people today - over
half the Jewish population of Israel – these indigenous 'Jews of
colour' never left the region, most refugees finding a haven in the
only state that would accept them unconditionally.
Arab and
Muslim antisemitism did not begin with the creation of Israel. For 14
centuries of Muslim rule Jews lived as a subjugated dhimmi minority with
few rights. Israel’s Mizrahi citizens will never agree to return to
‘colonised’ dhimmi status in a Corbyn-approved majority-Arab state.
The Arab and Muslim quarrel with Israeli ‘imperialism’ becomes absurd
when viewed against the World Organisation of Jews from Arab Countries
claim that Jews lost more than the Palestinians - including
privately-owned land in Arab states equivalent to five times the size of
Israel.
The far left believes that Israel has genocidal designs
on the Palestinians reminiscent of the Nazis. The myth of the Arabs as
innocent bystanders, who had no responsibility for the Holocaust—and
indeed, paid the price for a European crime when Israel was
established—is a tenet of Corbynism.
Truth be told, Arabs
overwhelmingly supported Nazism and imported the anti-Jewish conspiracy
theories rife in the Muslim world today. Antisemitism is a core belief
of the Muslim Brotherhood, and their ideological cousins, Islamic State.
The wartime Palestinian Mufti's collaboration with the Nazis was not
simply a pragmatic anti-colonial alliance. Had Nazism triumphed, the
Mufti would have overseen the extermination of the Jews of the Arab
world as well as in Palestine. The Mufti’s anti-Jewish genocidal project
is enshrined in the Hamas charter and kept alive today by the
Ayatollahs of Iran.
Finally, Corbyn sees the Arabs, like other
Third World peoples, solely as victims of Western colonialism,
incapable of oppressing others. The West overlooks their misdeeds. For
example, the Taubira law memorialising slavery (adopted in France in
2001) mentioned the 11 million victims of the transatlantic slave trade,
while ignoring the 17 million slaves trafficked by Arabs and Muslims.
Corbyn and his acolytes are cheerleaders for the true forces of (Arab and Muslim)
imperialism in the Middle East. The Palestinians are the foot-soldiers
in a pan-Arab, and now Islamist struggle – couched in terms of
‘Palestinian rights’ - to abolish the Jewish state and re-establish
Arab-Muslim majority control. The Arabs already have 22 states, but
Corbyn has never advocated for the suppressed rights of indigenous
Kurds, Baloch, Berbers and Assyrians.
The Jewish nakba vindicates
a sovereign Jewish state in the region. As an aboriginal Middle Eastern
people, Jews have an inalienable right, enshrined in the UN Declaration
on the Rights of Indigenous peoples, to self-determination.
Corbyn’s worldview may be too entrenched to change. The pity is that
young people are growing up with a similarly distorted view of the
Middle East, fuelled by media bias, in which in Israel uniquely evil and
the Palestinians the sole victims of injustice. More alarmingly, if
Corbyn’s hostility to Jews is mainstreamed, most ordinary folk would
give a shrug of indifference.
Read article in full (p.32)
No comments:
Post a Comment