A refugee or transit camp (ma'abara) in Nahariya
Solid evidence that Jews were being 'pushed' from Arab countries in the early years of Israel's establishment comes from Israel's National Archivist. The largest numbers (12, 000 in three months) were projected from Iraq in 1950. But 10, 000 were also arriving from Romania, and the state was faced with the agonising decision: which refugees should be given priority? (With thanks: Silke)
Today's document gives a taste of the atmosphere Israeli immigration
officials operated in during the summer of 1950, when mass immigration
of almost penniless immigrants had simply become the natural way of the
world. It was penned by one Itzhak Refael, who later went on to become
one of the leaders of the National Religious Party; the three-page
document gives the projections for immigration in the coming three
months (after June 1950). The purpose is to control the pace of
arrivals, although, as Refael notes, this is only partially possible.
The immigration from Arab lands, he explains, is motivated by distress,
and if conditions get worse we can't keep people out. (My emphasis -ed)
Which is an interesting point, since present-day polemicists love to
argue about whether the Jews were being forced out of the Arab lands,
and were thus refugees, or they were coming because of religious belief
in the centrality of Israel and the sudden possibility to move to a
Jewish state, so they were immigrants (or worse, colonialists). As if
there's necessarily a contradiction between being pushed and pulled.
Read post in full
Most pre-1952 immigrants were from Muslim lands
I think this is a good occasion to do one of my Israel is unique in the neighbourhood rants.
ReplyDeletewhich of her neighbours have accessible and publishing state archives?
only those who have archives who match Israel's are IMHO opinion entitled to have their "narratives" considered as more than mere newspaper reports.
Turkey's FM Davutoglu mentioned in his AlJazeera interview Istanbul archives.
Of course there must be archives in Turkey but an institution called "Istanbul archives" - at least I have never heard it mentioned.