Panoramic view of Algiers
It is 70 years since Operation Torch - the Allied invasion - began the liberation of North Africa from the Nazis and their collaborators. Point of No Return flagged an article by David B Green in Haaretz on the subject. But our knowledgeable commenter Eliyahu points out that the US liberation of Algeria would not have gone so smoothly, and certainly not without loss of life, had the Algerian underground, 85% Jewish, not paved the way for their arrival by taking over key strategic points. David Green's article makes no mention of this fact:
Eliyahu writes:
This article by David Green is OK as far as it goes. But it is woefully
incomplete, probably through no fault of the author. In fact, a group of
Algerian Jews in the Resistance did a great deal to help Operation
Torch succeed. Whereas more than 500 American soldiers died in the
landing at Casablanca, none died landing at Algiers because in Algiers
the Underground, about 85% Jewish, made a coup d'etat, taking over the
sensitive nodes of political/military control in Algiers, the capital of
French North Africa, on the eve of the US landing and in coordination
with it. This story is missing in most American accounts of WW2 and the
war in the Mediterranean, but I can say about the Algiers Underground
what Churchill said about the RAF in the Battle of Britain. Seldom have
so few saved so many.
The ingratitude of official US institutions and
personalities is striking. Official US Army accounts of the war omit
mention of help for the US by natives in North Africa but for one book
that mentions the Algiers uprising in a few lines without any mention
that most were Jews. The US consul in Algiers at the time [the US was
not at war with Vichy], Robert Murphy, worked with the Underground up to
a point and supplied one rifle or carbine to the resistance fighters
[General Mark Clark had supplied another]. Yet in his book of memoirs,
Diplomat Among Warriors, Murphy only fuzzily alludes to the resistance,
again without mentioning that they were mostly Jews. Moreover, he
refused to help Jose Aboulker who was arrested and jailed by the
dissident Vichyites who took over Algeria under American sponsorship
after the landing. This is part of the background of Rafael Medoff's
account which also overlooks the Underground [Knowing Rafi, I assume
that he just didn't know of it, omitted as it is from American accounts
of the war].
Here are sources on the events in English, French and Hebrew:
Gita Amipaz-Silber, La Resistance juive en Algerie, 1940-1942 [Jerusalem: Rubin Mass 1986]
--(same author in Hebrew)-- מחתרת יהודית באלג'ריה- 1940-1942
[Tel Aviv: Ministry of Defense Publishing House 1983]
--(there is also an English translation. I don't know the title)
--Elliot A Green, "Jewish Anti-Nazi Resistance in Wartime Algeria" in Midstream (New York, January 1989)
--also see articles by David Corcos in Encyclopedia Judaica about Algiers and Algeria.
--
Leon Poliakov writes about the Algiers Underground in his article about
the Jews in France [including North Africa] during the Shoah in the
Yiddish-language Algemeyner Entsiklopedya, Series "Yidn," vol. zayin, pp
188-191. Poliakov stresses the importance of the Algiers Underground to
the success of the Allied landing, that is, the success of Operation
Torch. Poliakov thinks that the landing would have ended in catastrophe
if not for the Algiers Underground. All things considered, gratitude for
the Underground's accomplishment has been less than deserved in France
and almost non-existent in America, judging by later publications.
Here's a favorable account of Jose Aboulker as leader of the coup d'etat in practice. Published in the American periodical Colliers Weekly. It's from 1945 and does not change my previously stated conclusion. How often was the episode referred to after 1945?
ReplyDeletehttp://www.unz.org/Pub/Colliers-1945jun16-00036
Another account of the events:
http://trove.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/article/11788144
another account:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.ushmm.org/wlc/en/article.php?ModuleId=10007312
We were saved by the Brits in the first place. Then followed by the 'yanks' as you say.
ReplyDeleteBut had it not been for the victory of Mongomery at El Alamein, that was in 1942 and Montgomery battled the Nazis at El Alamein.
Every day there were raids and we had to rush to the shelters, a horrendous place where we all gathered and waited.
My mother was heavily pregnant about to give birth.
Later it was the Yanks as you called them who who saved my newlyborn sister from death with the Pennicilin they had at their disposal.
For the rest of the war, I got to love these American guys who gave me chocolate and whi shared parcels received from home;
Well maybe all this is out of context but you brought this back to memory.
Gosh i must be terribly old!
suzy vidal
and at the same time my arab father was beaten by the french colonial army.
ReplyDelete