Wednesday, December 03, 2008

The myth of Arab innocence

Writing in History News Network Elliott A Green deconstructs the myth that Arabs and Palestinians were innocent victims of Israel. Not only were the Jews the objects of deep-seated Muslim contempt, he argues, but the Palestinian leader, the Mufti of Jerusalem, was guilty of collusion with the Nazis' extermination project.

The myth of Arab innocence throughout history --particularly concerning Jews-- has long haunted British and American writing about the Arab-Israeli conflict. Professors Walt and Mearsheimer put it as follows in their anti-Israel tract: the Christian West... Jews suffered greatly from the despicable legacy of Anti-Semitism... But ... the creation of Israel involved additional crimes against a largely innocent third party: the Palestinians.

This article seeks to disprove that false claim and demonstrate instead the systemic, juridical oppression, exploitation, and humiliation of non-Muslims --including Jews--in Islamic society. Further, whereas it used to be commonly believed that Islam was benign toward Jews, the article shows that Jews were at the bottom of the social barrel in the Islamic domain generally--although conditions varied with time and place. Moreover, this was true in Jerusalem specifically. Indeed, the famous Jewish philosopher Maimonides believed that Jews were worse treated under Islam than in Christendom. He was in a position to compare conditions in both zones because he conducted correspondence with Jews in far flung places.

Read article in full


Anonymous said...

This article is one-sided, racist and ignorant. I'll refute this trash sometime this week when I have some time to spare.

Anonymous said...

Dear Esra'a, I'm not holding my breath for your reply.

Anonymous said...

Oh 7aram Esra'a ya miskeena, anything that is in the least bit critical of Arabs or Muslims is automatically "racist" and "trash". Of course we all have to accept everything Arabs claim as the truth, and anything from Jews is "zionist lies" "propaganda" et al. My family is originally from Iraq and they witnessed first hand the Farhud massacre in Baghdad against the Jews in 1941 which was inspired by the grand mufti of Jerusalem 7ajj Amin Al-Husseini, al-tasqeet when Iraqi Jews were stripped of their citizenship, the anti-Jewish legislations, the confiscation of their properties, homes, assets, the rampaging mobs screaming "itba7 al yahud" and their eventual expulsion from the land they have inhabited for over 2,000 years. But of course, these are all "racist lies". Bravo 3aleki

Eliyahu m'Tsiyon said...

Doesn't Esra'a or Isra`a refer to Muhammad's supposed Night Journey??

If not, what does the the moniker Esra`a mean anyhow??