Tuesday, February 13, 2018

Did Bob Marley have Syrian-Jewish roots?

With thanks: Michelle

Well I never. The late reggae legend Bob Marley had Jewish roots.


 The World Jewish Congress tells us so, so it must be true. In fact the WJC has gone to the lengths of making a video giving special mention to Bob Marley in a potted history of Jewish Jamaica, the Caribbean island where Marley was born.

According to the video, Bob Marley's father was a Jamaican called Norval. But Norval's mother was Ellen Broomfield, a (white) Syrian Jew.

Quite what a Syrian Jew was doing in Jamaica, the WJC does not tell us.

Hang on a minute! This website says that Ellen Broomfield was a coloured Jamaican. And this website says:

"There is unsubstantiated information circulating that Ellen was a Syrian Jew, but the name is not Syrian or Jewish and is an old Jamaican/English name.
A "wedding certificate for the marriage of Robert Marley [Bob's paternal grandfather] and Ellen Bloomfield [his paternal grandmother] lists him as 'white' and her as 'colored'."

Sorry to disappoint you, folks. The balance of probability is that Marley's grandmother was not Jewish. But take crumbs of comfort in the fact that Marley seems to have been a philosemite. And his own son Julian (below left) has visited Israel.


20 comments:

Anonymous said...

Marley’s son Ziggy is marred to an Israeli from Kfar Saba. Her family is originally from Iran.

by Davsil said...

I believe Bob Marley himself mentioned that he was of Sephardic ancestry.

Anonymous said...

Here it says Bob Marley's father was Jewish:
https://www.algemeiner.com/2012/02/06/bob-marley-and-the-jews/

Anonymous said...

More here about Ziggy:

https://www.algemeiner.com/2016/11/02/jamaican-reggae-great-ziggy-marley-on-mixed-marriage-blended-cultures-israeli-wife-introduced-me-to-felafel/

bataween said...

These articles recycle the notion that the Marleys have Jewish ancestry, but do not add anything more concrete about the so-called Jewish roots of Norval's mother.

Anonymous said...

It would be challenging to find a Jamaican who did not have some Jewish roots: http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jamaica-virtual-jewish-history-tour
--malca

Anonymous said...

claims that broomfield is actually bloomfield
https://www.geni.com/people/Richard-Bloomfield/6000000011691448022
--malca

Anonymous said...

My error -- references to Jewish roots end up being circular, without documentary basis.
--malca

bataween said...

It could be that most Jamaicans have Jewish ancestry. Broomflied or Bloomfield has never been a Sephardi name, however.

RuthRachelAA said...

Sad. And offensive, quite frankly.

This blog post speaks of philo-semitism, while its own philo-racism (purporting to "love" people with African, and, particularly, Sub-Saharan African, heritage until, by your own estimation, you no longer have something to gain from associating with them), if I may call it that, is brushed under the rug.

For those who are uninformed, many Syrian, Lebanese and Egyptian Christians and Jews immigrated to Jamaica during the 18th and 19th centuries.

Some of the Misrahi Jews among those who immigrated to the island intermarried with persons of Christian English, Scottish, Irish, Spanish, German or African descent, among other lines of descent.

This is, indeed, the case within my own family, in which my Syrian Jewish great-grandmother married a Christian Scottish man (who was neither Jamaican by birth or nationality, but a subject of the British crown) in Jamaica. Therefore, my last name is of Scottish origin, and I have an authentic Scottish Tartan in addition to the newly introduced Jewish Tartan (which I also love), while my paternal Jewish heritage is Syrian Misrahi.

Indeed, persons who are paternal descendants of intermarriages between a Jewish mother and a non-Jewish father will not carry a traditionally Jewish surname (unless that non-Jewish father somehow carried a traditionally Jewish surname). Indeed, Bob Marley's own Jewish grandchildren, born to a non-Jewish father, Ziggy Marley (Bob Marley's son), and an Israeli Iranian Jewish mother, Orly Marley (Bob Marley's posthumous daughter-in-law), carry a non-Jewish English last name: Marley.

Persons who are maternal descendants of intermarriages between a non-Jewish mother and a Jewish father will carry a Jewish surname (unless that Jewish father somehow carried a non-Jewish surname), but are not halakhically Jewish. Paternal descendants of such intermarriages may or may not be Jewish according to halakha, depending upon the heritage of the mother.

Persons who are familiar with doing genealogies are aware of such realities...

Anonymous said...

Thank you for you interesting contribution confirming your own Syrian-Jewish ancestry. Yes it is quite plausible that Bob Marley could be descended from a Syrian Jewess, ( it would not make Marley halachically Jewish, as the link would be through his father Norval) but we do not know enough about Marley's genealogy to be able to confirm whether Ellen Broomfield was Jewish. Her maiden name would have given us an important clue.
I do not see why you found this blog 'sad and offensive ' and smacking of 'philoracism' and do not understand what you mean by loving Africans only if there is something to be gained by associating with them. Huh?The blog was simply speculating on Marley's possible heritage and even if his Jewish origins could not be proven, he was still a friend of the Jewish people.






RuthRachelAA said...

When mainstream Jewish and Israeli media seeks or needs to make an appeal to non-Jewish ethnic communities of color for political purposes, the heritage of well-known, brown-skinned Jews with Sub-Saharan African heritage like Drake, Alicia Keys, Lisa Bonet, Halle Berry or Cory Booker, or of brown-skinned people with both Sub-Saharan African and Jewish heritage like Bob Marley, is publicly called upon for marketing purposes over and over and over again. How many articles about Bob Marley's Jewish heritage did I read during the eight years that Barack Obama was President of the United States...? I wasn't keeping count.

When Bob Marley's own brown-skinned, non-Jewish descendants seek to personally affirm these same Jewish roots, self-proclaimed "gatekeepers" within the Jewish community personally take it upon themselves to call into question this very same Jewish heritage previously marketed for political purposes in a way that they would not have done had Bob Marley's descendants looked "white".

Just prior to Meghan Markle's engagement to Prince Harry, articles speculating that Meghan Markle is Jewish or has Jewish heritage started appearing in media all over the world. But Meghan Markle isn't Jewish (and does not seem to have any Jewish heritage, actually, by her own statement), while there are many, many other people with Sub-Saharan African heritage who do, indeed, have Jewish heritage, or who are, indeed, Jewish according to halakha, whose Jewish roots and identity are constantly called into question.

Brown-skinned Jews (people who are ethnically and halakhically Jewish by birth!) -Ashkenazi, Musta'arabi, Misrahi, Sepharadi, Beta Israeli - with both Jewish and non-Jewish Sub-Saharan African heritage sometimes get turned away from attending services in synagogue because of the way that they "look"...in Europe, in the United States, in Israel, even...but are regularly encouraged to participate in all sorts of political events in support of the Jewish community and the State of Israel. (And please, don't call me a "self-hating Jew" or "anti-Israel", because I love myself as a Jew, and I love Israel, and regularly contribute to the well-being of the Jewish Diaspora and the State of Israel...)

Mainstream media sometimes pits brown-skinned Jews (people who are ethnically and halakhically Jewish by birth!) with Jewish or non-Jewish Sub-Saharan African heritage against converts with Sub-Saharan African heritage in an attempt to deny their Jewish heritage and identity (à la "the converted Jews are 'more Jewish' than..."). Rather than seek the political opinion of brown-skinned Jews (people who are ethnically and halakhically Jewish by birth!) with Jewish or non-Jewish Sub-Saharan African heritage, mainstream media seeks out the the vocal opinions of brown-skinned non-Jews (possibly with Jewish heritage) such as Chloé Valdary (no personal judgment of Ms. Valdary, with whom I sometimes may agree or disagree, intended).

In fact, I just watched a video earlier today in which Jewish Israelis were asked to respond to the question: "Do you think the Government is doing the right thing with African migrants?" None of the persons featured in the video responses to this question are Ethiopian Jews or Jews with any Sub-Saharan African heritage...the opinion of an Armenian Christian on the question was considered more important than theirs...

It is, indeed, "sad and offensive". And it is "philo-racism".

Mainstream media needs to stop exploiting, rewriting, or simply omitting the heritage and identity of brown-skinned Jews and descendants of Jews with Sub-Saharan African heritage for political purposes, and needs to start defending their heritage and identity in sincerity (on the level of soul, "nefesh yehudi" and "nefesh", "Leshem Shemayim"), as fellow Jews and people with Jewish heritage.

RuthRachelAA said...

(And, oh, Barack Obama isn't Jewish, either...)

bataween said...

Hi Ruth Rachel
Thank you for your explanation. I don't agree that the Jewish heritage of brown-skinned people is invoked for 'marketing or political purposes'. Jews love to "kvell" and revel in the celebrity and achievements of their own. There are always rumours that a new celebrity is Jewish: I can remember when Prince William got engaged to Catherine there were rumours that she was Jewish, and she is not a person of colour! If Jews value the opinions of non- Jews like Chloe Valdari and Dumisani Washington it is because they swim against the anti-Zionist groupthink among people of colour.

RuthRachelAA said...

Bataween,

Many thanks for your response (in addition to that of Anonymous, who I failed to thank in my prior post above in the rush to respond in a timely manner - many thanks to you, Anonymous, as well).

True that we love to revel in community celebrity and achievements, and this is a good thing if and when done in a positive way, but the true measure of a person is how he or she treats everyday people, people who are not in the spotlight (as demonstrated by the Purim traditions of Mishloah Manot and Matanot L'Evyonim...).

True that there are always rumors that this or that celebrity or public figure is (or isn't) Jewish - and I do remember the same dynamic in play with Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge..., but the fact remains that there are entire populations of fellow Jews who are largely marginalized within the Jewish community (whatever their tradition) UNLESS they have achieved the status of an elite, a celebrity or a public figure (and here Musta'arabim, Misrahim, Sepharadim, and Beta Israel are not forgotten...). Herein lies the problem. Moreover, the fact that a similar dynamic was put into play with the Duchess of Cambridge merely carries my point into the larger community, beyond the fallacy of the social construct of "race" and "colorism"...

It is also true, in a literal sense, that non-Jewish persons of color who are supporters of Israel, such as Chloé Valdary and Dumisani Washington, "swim against the anti-Zionist groupthink among people of colour", as you have so framed it (a bit of a loaded phrase, in my humble opinion, that implies that people of color are not "freethinkers" in their thoughts about Israel, whatever they may be, but, for lack of time, a debate on this singular point is not the central focus of the present discussion). However, such voices should not displace, or serve as a replacement for, the voices of Jews of color who are ethnically and halakhically Jewish by birth (or by conversion, for that matter, remaining true to halakha, even considering the existence of the Edict for Syrian Jews), whatever their opinions (which sometimes may be opinions which people do not wish to hear, for whatever reason).

For the moment, I seek to address what I see as lacking in mainstream Diaspora and Israel media by working to create media which addresses my concerns. "Be the solution to the problem that you seek to solve."

Thus, "agreeing to disagree", I'll leave my thoughts on the matter here, for your further consideration.

RuthRachelAA said...

Please excuse me, but I have one final thought:

I have even personally witnessed Musta'arabi, Misrahi, Sepharadi Jews who are very well achieved (very well-educated, well-traveled, well-spoken) become marginalized within the Jewish community.

Even Jews of color who become part of an elite, who obtain celebrity, or who are held in the public eye may still be marginalized within the Jewish community...because of the way in which the fallacy of the social constructs of "race" and "colorism" impact the way in which a person is received (or not received).

bataween said...

Hi Ruth yes I quite agree with you, there is a curious phenomenon of marginalisation and I enjoyed our exchange. Btw thevAnonymous was me too!

RuthRachelAA said...

Bataween,

Thank you. I enjoyed our exchange, as well.

(Quite frankly, I almost chose to post as "Anonymous", too...No worries.)

Anonymous said...

I had to look it up! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musta%27arabim

Anyone find it off-putting to delve into the possible Jewish heritage of the Grateful Dead's Jerry Garcia? (didn't think so.)
--malca

Anonymous said...

But all this is complicated by the fact that before becoming a British colony, Jamaica was the home to Jews who fled Spain. Read Jewish Pirates of the Caribbean to learn more.