Friday, March 23, 2012

Pro-Jewish Muslim students suffered antisemitism


With thanks: Michelle-Malca

With the Arab and Muslim world convulsed by antisemitism, two Moroccan Muslim students must be congratulated for bucking the trend: they have set up the Mimouna Club at Ifrane university.

The purpose of the Mimouna Club, named after the Moroccan-Jewish celebration that concludes Passover during which Jews traditionally invited Muslims into their homes for a feast, is to promote the idea of Jewish-Muslim coexistence and to recall Morocco's Jewish heritage.

It is the nostalgia of his grandmother's generation for the Jews - she was one of very few Muslims living in the Casablanca Jewish ghetto and attending the Jewish (Alliance) school - that motivated El-Mehdi Boudra to set up his club, with the encouragement of Andre Azoulay, the Moroccan king's Jewish adviser. In the case of Laaziza Dalil, it was the fact she had grown up with many Jewish friends. Both were interviewed on the John Batchelor radio show in New York by Jewish leader Malcolm Hoenlein on 22 March. (Segment starts 11 minutes into the programme).

It is interesting that two Moroccans with no Jewish blood or connections have themselves experienced antisemitism: When the Mimouna Club was first set up, it was denigrated as the 'Mellah' (Jewish ghetto). Someone daubed a swastika. Laaziza Dalil was shocked and deeply upset by an antisemitic encounter in Paris with an old lady who mistook her for a Sephardi Jew. 'Things were better when Paris was cleansed (of Jews) by the Germans', the old lady sneered. Although their parents are largely supportive, El-Mehdi's father fears that his son's involvement with the Mimouna Club will later put at risk his chances of finding a job. The two students are aware that the affection of their grandparents' generation towards Jews has been replaced with fierce anti-Jewish hatred among the youth.

The Mimouna Club has plans to organise a trip by Moroccan students to Israel. It has also worked with US interfaith organisations to hold the first conference ever on the Holocaust in the Arab world, and made a film about it. ' We don't need to deny the Holocaust,' El-Mehdi declares triumphantly,' because of the actions of King Mohammed V.'

While Malcolm Hoenlein gushes his approval of this initiative, I beg to differ. The wartime king Mohammed V (pictured) was said to have saved Jews from deportation to the death camps. But the Vichy government did not attempt to deport them. The king did not prevent Moroccan Jews from being shunted back into their ghettos. He did not prevent Jews being sacked from their jobs and subject to quotas and restrictions under the Vichy 'statut des juifs'. He had nothing to say about the hundreds of European Jews who died in forced labour camps on Moroccan territory. And if he was powerless to prevent these things, why exaggerate his role and elevate him to sainthood?

Laudable efforts to educate Arabs about the Holocaust run the risk of whitewashing the record if they only tell one side of the story. Attempts to show only stories of rescue and sympathy among Arabs for Jews, when plenty of others were ready to betray them and sympathise with the Nazis, become distortions of history.

Moroccan Holocaust conference has its dangers

8 comments:

Stop Islamaphobia said...

Arabs may be more open to acknowledge the Jewish holocaust if Jews (and others) are more open to recognize Islamaphobia.

bataween said...

There are eight times as many incidents of antisemitism as islamophobia in the UK. The two are not equivalent.

Anonymous said...

I'd like to add that the two are totally disproportionate.And besides Jews do not go round trying to kill Muslims.
Islamophobia unfortunately started after the 9/11 attacks on the towers. I have Muslim neighbours and we get along very well, though to be honest we never invite them or they invite us. What a pity!
sultana

Anonymous said...

"There are eight times as many incidents of antisemitism as islamophobia in the UK"

And most of the anti semitic incidents are committed by Muslims.



__________________
Jews of the Arab World Are Already Home

http://www.commentarymagazine.com/2012/03/23/jews-arab-world-already-home-foreign-policy/

Anonymous said...

One more:

Latest FBI Hate Crimes Stats: 2/3 of Incidents Against Jews; 12% “Against” Muslims

Of the 1,552 victims of an anti-religion hate crime:

- 67.0 percent were victims of an offender’s anti-Jewish bias.
- 12.7 percent were victims of an anti-Islamic bias.
- 4.2 percent were victims of an anti-Catholic bias.
- 3.0 percent were victims of an anti-Protestant bias.
- 0.5 percent were victims of an anti-Atheist/Agnostic bias.
- 9.1 percent were victims of a bias against other religions (anti-other religion).
- 3.5 percent were victims of a bias against groups of individuals of varying religions (anti-multiple religions, group).

halal pork said...

Our Muslim friend lives in his own little world.

Arabs already acknowledge the Jewish Holocaust, that's why Hitler is a hero in the Arab world and Mein Kampf is second only to the qur'an there.

In his head, Arabs "may be(!) more open to acknowledge" a fact beyond dispute IF Jews are willing to recognize a publicity stunt used to silence honest criticism of his religion and Muslim behavior.

I've seen Melanie Phillips, Charles Krauthammer, Daniel Pipes, Bernard Lewis and, even the Pope, being called islamophobes.
You're not in Egypt. The Islamic religion can and should be criticized. Deal with it.

Anonymous said...

Isn't there any percentage of happy non-violent people?

Anonymous said...

I don't know if such thing exists, but if it does I'm sure its numbers would decrease after such a smart comment.