Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Recalling the Jewish Nakba in the 'Middle East', W2



(Top) Some 80 people heard the harrowing stories of refugees from Egypt, Libya and Iraq. (Middle) Tom Gross and Michelle Huberman. (Bottom) Refugee from Iraq Nadia Nathan holds the award presented on Harif's behalf by Tom Gross to Rosemond Nissan for her work with refugees. (Photos: Gili and Niran)

If they want Islamic banking, crave Lebanese mezze at the dozens of restaurants and kebab houses, or hanker for a hookah pipe, the cognoscenti head for the Edgware Road, W2, in London. Here the hijab-clad women and Arabic signage make you feel, for all the world, that you are in the Middle East.

And so it was a trifle daunting - but also appropriate - that Sunday's event concerning the Jews of the Middle East and North Africa, Harif's The Jewish Nakba:remembering Jewish refugees from Arab countries, should have been held in the heart of London's Levant.

The police, however, were taking no chances. Guests had to brave a ring of steely officers on entry to the hotel, going through airport-style security so tight that some bona fide latecomers were turned away. The organisers were not allowed to advertise their meeting lest the expression Jewish Nakba appearing on a hotel screen might incite some hothead with a kebab skewer to go on the rampage.

The date chosen was deliberate: 15 May was Nakba Day for the Palestinians, but it was also an opportunity to tell the world about a second Nakba - the mass displacement of almost a million Jews from the Arab world.

Before an audience of 80 people, Jewish refugees told their harrowing stories. Colette Littman was forced to flee Egypt in 1956 after days of listening to the mob screaming Ytbah al yahud in the streets of Cairo below her apartment.The family's cook Omar was found sharpening a kitchen knife: what was he doing? she asked him. 'Getting ready to kill the Jews', came the reply.

Colette left with only the clothes she was wearing and her suitcase was ransacked at the airport. Not only did Egyptian Jews face an uncertain future in exile, but they underwent the emotional trauma of seeing their communities destroyed and their families scattered to the ends of the earth.

Elia Meghnagi left Benghazi in Libya in 1958 to study abroad. His early memories are of brawls between Arab and Jewish youths. As a stateless student in England, he was forced to support himself. Later, he arranged for his family to join him, but they had to leave all their property and belongings behind. They quietly slipped out, leaving the table set as if for a meal so as not to arouse the neighbours' suspicions. Back in England, visiting the Libyan embassy in order to regularise his status, Elia narrowly escaped being bundled into a plane and forcibly returned to Libya.

Edwin Shuker's family had lived in Mesopotamia - now Iraq - for 2,700 years. One of five thousand Jews still left in the country after the mass exodus of 1950 -51, Edwin witnessed the noose tightening around the community's necks in the sixties, when Jews had to carry yellow identity papers. Then came the horrific hangings of 1969, when a mob half a million strong picknicked under the corpses of nine innocent Jews suspended from the gallows in the main square. Edwin's family had to leave like thieves in the night, abandoning 2,700 years of history behind them.

Dr Saul Zadka, academic, author and journalist, who described himself as a 'refugee at heart', gave an incisive political analysis of the refugee issue. The two cases were quite different. Some 100,000 Palestinian 'refugees' belonging to well-to-do families left the country a year earlier with their money and belongings with every intention of returning when the Jews had been crushed. A million Arabs, many of them hostile to Israel, lived as full citizens with more rights than any of their fellow countrymen in Arab states. Jews in Arab lands were loyal citizens, yet were rewarded with murderous riots in Iraq, Libya and Aden before the creation of Israel. It was a hopeful development that the US Congress had passed a resolution in 2008 demanding parity between Jewish and Palestinian refugees, but the Israeli government was still doing too little, too late. Dr Zadka himself distributed a statement to the audience demanding that Jewish refugee rights be recognised and compensation for property many times more valuable than Palestinian losses, as the Jews were big city dwellers while the Palestinians were largely poor farmers who supported the invading armies.

Following a showing of the 15-minute short version of the film 'Forgotten Refugees', the international relations expert Tom Gross said that the Jewish refugee issue was in many ways the single most important issue on the Middle East agenda. " In theory Borders can be agreed and Jerusalem can be divided, but there is no answer to appeasing the feelings and demands of Palestinians and their supporters regarding the so-called 'right of return' - apart from making them aware of the suffering and the loss of the refugees of the Jewish Nakba, " he said. Yet few knew about it - and he seriously doubted if Prime Minister David Cameron and Foreign Secretary William Hague had even heard of it. As far as Israel advocacy was concerned, no session at the 'We believe in Israel' conference taking place that day dealt with the topic. As for the press and media, they were mesmerised with the Palestinian Nakba to the exclusion of other news and other refugees.

On behalf of Harif, Tom Gross presented an award to Mrs Rosemond Nissan, who had devoted 33 years to helping refugees from the Middle East at World Jewish Relief. Michelle Huberman spoke of what tools could be used to promote Jewish refugees: she unveiled Harif's new Mezuzah campaign, recalling the stolen Jewish homes in Arab lands - every activist's must-have accessory.

As they stepped back out on to the Edgware Road, the ex-refugees in the audience went away fired up with renewed enthusiasm to tell their stories. Indignant Israel advocates prepared to vent their outrage at this neglected issue in letters to the editor - and the hungry simply went off in search of a hummus and pitta in London's 'Middle East'.

Crossposted at Harry's Place

video

9 comments:

Sylvia said...

Excellent. Next year, efforts should be made long in advance to have the story in the New York Times. perhaps even throughout the year.
Just don't get Roger Cohen. He'll turn life of humiliation and uncertainty into bliss.

Anonymous said...

once i listened to a palestinian leader and he said:
We rely on our wopen's belly to citizens to overthrow el yahud (Jews)
And now they are so numerous that everyone is willing to take out a piece of
Jewish teritory to give them a country.Poor things!!!
Sultana Latifa
A Jewish refugee from Egypt

Anonymous said...

please exucse my typing mistakes:

of course i meant "our women's belly, to produce enough citizens"
So sorry.
suzy

MichelleInSanDiego said...

http://www.harif.org/nakba.html

http://www.spiroark.org/events/755/the-last-jews-of-libya/
http://www.facebook.com/event.php?eid=105165542903461

Were the latter two events actually held at the same locale, as apparently planned?

bataween said...

You are right that the latter two events were/will be at the West London synagogue. I do hope that the people who were at the May 15 event will also come to the Last Jews of Libya on 15 June - they might learn something new!

Anonymous said...

Dr Zadka himself distributed a statement to the audience demanding that Jewish refugee rights be recognised and compensation for property many times more valuable than Palestinian losses, as the Jews were big city dwellers while the Palestinians were largely poor farmers who supported the invading armies.

A paragraph befroe this they were wealthy Arabs leaving with all their money intending to return when israel was crushed.

Which is it ?

bataween said...

There is no contradiction. The wealthy Arabs left Jaffa, Haifa and Jerusalem, but thse were provincial towns and their assets were small fry compared to what Jews lost in major cities in the Middle East - Baghdad, Cairo, Tripoli, etc.

YJ Draiman for Mayor of LA said...

When the issue of refugees is raised within the context of the Middle East, people invariably refer to Palestinian refugees, virtually never to Jews displaced from Arab countries.


In reality, two major population movements occurred as a result of over a half century of turmoil in the Middle East. Securing rights for these former Jewish refugees has never been adequately addressed by the international community. For any peace process to be credible and enduring, it must address the rights of all Middle East refugees, including Jewish and other minority populations that were displaced from Arab countries.


Historically, Jews and Jewish communities have existed in the Middle East, North Africa and the Gulf region for more than 2,500 years. Jews in substantial numbers resided in what are to-day Arab countries over 1,000 years before the advent of Islam. Following the Moslem conquest of the region, for centuries, while relegated to second-class status, Jews were nonetheless permitted limited religious, educational, professional, and business opportunities.


It is important to note that the treatment of Jews by Arab leaders and Islamic populations varied greatly from country to country. By way of example, in some countries, Jews were forbidden to leave (e.g. Syria); in others, many Jews were expelled (e.g. Egypt) or displaced en masse (e.g. Iraq); while other Jewish communities lived in relative peace under the protection of Muslim rulers (e.g. Tunisia, Morocco).


When Arab countries gained independence, followed by the rise in Arab nationalism, state-sanctioned measures, coupled often with violence and repression, made remaining in the land of their birth an untenable option for Jews.


In 1948, the status of Jews in Arab countries worsened dramatically as many Arab countries declared war, or backed the war against the newly founded State of Israel. Jews were either uprooted from their countries of longtime residence or became subjugated, political hostages of the Arab-Israeli conflict. In virtually all cases, as Jews left the country, individual and communal properties were confiscated without compensation.

Mizra7i said...

Do you realise that West London Synagogue has existed in the 'Heart of London's Levant' for decades right next door to a Lebanese supermarket and has NEVER had a single problem!?
To use words like being worried about a "hot head with a kebab skewer" plays right into the hands of those that would accuse Jewish organisations of orientalist-based racism.