Tuesday, October 06, 2009

Mizrahim 'had it better' under Islam - Gorenberg

Gershom Gorenberg has a theory that Yom Kippur is somehow jollier when you're a Mizrahi Jew. He has another theory: it's because Jews were more 'accepted', and life was less 'precarious' under Islam than in Christendom ( tell that to a Jewish orphan forcibly converted in Yemen or the terrifed inhabitant of a Moroccan mellah overrun by hotblooded rioters). But Gershom's biggest clanger, in this South Jerusalem piece, is to claim that traditional attacks are always to be found against Christians in Ashkenazi prayers, never against Muslims in the Sephardi liturgy. Gershom, you've obviously never been to a Sephardi Rosh Hashana seder, where God is entreated to 'cut off our enemies' - and more than once! (With thanks: binhaddou )

"It was our first time spending that long day of prayer and fasting with mizrahi Jews. We were used to the mournful melodies of Ashkenazim on the edge of bursting into tears. In Bangkok, standing before heavily judgment, the Jews rocked. “Hatanu lefanekha, rahem aleinu” – “We have sinned before you, have mercy on us,” they belted out, as if no thought could be happier.

"When we arrived back in Jerusalem, somewhere just before Hanukkah, we told our friend Eric, who’d been housesitting our micro-apartment, about the difference between Ashkenazim and mizrahim on the day of divine judgment.

"Eric is a defense attorney. He thought for about 3 seconds and said, “See, these two guys have their day in court. The first one is led in, sees the judge, and thinks, ‘Oy, what I’ve done,’ and wails, “Judge, have mercy, mercy.

“The other come comes in and looks around. ‘That’s the judge what let me off last year!’ he says, and then loud and happy, “Hiya, Yer Honor!”

"The instant allegory perfectly describes two opposing ways of thinking about the human relationship with God as judge. Like my friend Bob, I certainly believe in the value of examining one’s deeds (the Hebrew word for “to pray” literally means “to judge oneself”) in order to change them. But I still prefer the joy of Sephardi prayers on the High Holy Days, the essentially positive view of the past and the future. If my own congregation, Yedidya, ever decided to send its sundry hazanim (prayer leaders) off for lessons in the traditional synagogue melodies of Baghdad and Aleppo, I’d walk to Yom Kippur services with a dance step.

"Anyway, I mentioned this story a week or so ago to a friend learned in Jewish history. “That’s the difference between people whose neighbors opposed their existence and people who were accepted as – even if second class – members of society.” (This isn’t an exact quote. I was sipping cinammon coffee at the time, not taking notes.)

"I wouldn’t want to attribute all the differences in Ashkenazi and Sephardi culture to the gap between how Christian Europe and the Muslim Middle East related to Jews. But I’d guess that it is one key reason. As I noted last year in an article on anti-gentile prayers that worked their way into Jewish liturgy and that should be removed:

Hebrew University historian Israel Yuval says that traditional liturgical attacks “are always against Christianity,” and are found in Ashkenazi prayers, not Sephardi ones. The rage reflects theological battles with Christianity, which claimed the Bible as its own and argued that Jews suffered in exile because God had ended the covenant with them. The Jewish response was a stress on “vengeful redemption”—looking forward to a conclusion of history in which the power relations were reversed, the Christians destroyed.

"While there were ups and downs in Jewish-gentile relations in both the Christian and the Islamic worlds, Jewish liturgy itself bears testimony that Jews felt that their lives were far more precarious among the Christians. Recently, in the midst of contemporary nonsense about the “Clash of Civilizations,” some rightwing Jews have made a habit of arguing that things were as bad or worse for Jews among the Muslims. The psychological record of the prayerbook says otherwise.

"A few days ago, for reasons I can’t remember at the moment, Myra mentioned to me the recent fad of older Jews from Iraqi Kurdistan taking organized tours to the old country, entering through Turkey. One old woman who lives on a moshav on the Lebanon border has talked on the radio about how she’s gone back twice, ignoring the security warnings from the Israeli government. The Kurdish Jews* like to see the places where they grew up and the Muslim friends they left behind. I suggested that this was more evidence that the lachrymose view of Jewish history in Muslim lands was questionable."

Read article in full

*The Kurdish example is exceptional. The Kurds have a history of collaborating with Israel in their struggle against Saddam and the Baathist government, and helped smuggle Jews out in their hour of need - ed.


Eliyahu m'Tsiyon said...

Gershom Gorenberg is a common 21st century phenomenon. He wants to be both a fashionable journalist and a respected intellectual. I think that he succeeds more as a journalist. That is, he is utterly shallow and ignorant. It seems as if he is unaware of all the books and articles that don't present the Jewish experience under Islam, as well as the more general dhimmi experience, in rosy hues.

He is aware of what he calls a "lachrymose" view of Jewish life in Muslim lands. But in his arrogance he decides that he doesn't have to accept it even in part. And his proof is the alleged evidence of the prayerbook. Apparently he never worshipped in the Sefardi synagogue in my neighborhood where the Simhat Torah songs include, if I recall rightly, יום שמחה לישראל יום אבל לישמעאל
That is, "A day of joy for Israel is a day of mourning for Ishmael." Why would they want to sing things like that?? They couldn't bear age-old resentment over Arab-Muslim oppression, could they? Of course, I mention these lyrics because they relate to Simhat Torah, coming up in a few days.

So let's go to the philosopher Maimonides, who was born in Spain, so he's about as Sefardi as you can get. He wrote in his famous Letter [or Epistle] to Yemen [אגרת תימן ] that the Arabs/Muslims were the most oppressive to Israel, the Jews, of all enemies and oppressors.

Curiously, Maimonides' remarks in this regard are found in an edition of his writings edited by David Hartman, who, like Gorenberg, considers himself to be "progreesive orthodox." Maybe Gorenberg could coordinate with Hartman. After all, Gorenberg's current informants and experts do not seem to be very knowledgeable.

That Gorenberg makes sweeping statements based on ignorance is a sure sign of the middle-middle brow ignoramus. How nice that GG knows academics at the university who are hardly less ignorant than he is on this matter!!

bataween said...

Ah, but Gorenberg would propably say that the Muslims Maimonides was talking about were not REAL Muslims, but the fanatical Almohades...

Ashkenazi Mizrahi said...

Excuse my French, but Gorenberg is nothing but a putz.

MichelleInSanDiego said...

If we look at Jews who have been compensated for their slave labor and stolen property, we find that Jews who suffered from the Nazi regime have a view of the world that includes the idea that material justice is attainable.

Jews from the Gulag do not receive compensation.

Jews who were forced to leave property behind elsewhere have not received compensation.

Consider, too, General Order No. 11 (1862), an explusion order in the US for Tennessee, Mississippi, and Kentucky, which was rescinded. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Order_No._11_(1862)
Jews in American had the confidence to gather support from Congress, the press, and the President.

I would measure "having it better" as whether Jews feel enough a part of their country of residence to expect fair treatment.

bataween said...

Interesting point, Michelle,. I would add that in the US and Europe to a lesser extent, Jews enjoyed certain rights which Jews in totalitarian states do not - hence many Jews in Arab countires never even bothered to register their property losses because they were so sure that compensation was as likely as a snowstorm in summer.